It is no surprise that I am fascinated by book covers and their diversity around the world. If we take a step backward and look at the process of designing THE cover of a book, there’s a lot of work that is not visible to the readers.

In this post share my thoughts about different versions of book covers that existed before the official book cover was created. During the iterative process there are many versions of the cover that do no make it. Some concepts are fully rejected, while others need multiple rounds of improvements in order to make all stakeholders happy.

Note: I did not read any of the books illustrated in this post. My comments are based only on the design of the cover and do not concern the content of the book.

How Democracy Ends by David Runciman

A book about politics with a bold touch. What better way to depict an end other than literally “not ending” the book cover? I like a lot the different approaches towards the unfinished touch – fading, crossing, cutting – and I completely agree that the final cover is the best one!

how democracy ends david runciman rejected book covers readers high tea
Cover designs by James Jones. Images from eyeondesign.aiga.org

The Optimistic Decade by Heather Abel

For “The Optimistic Decade” it seems that the initial direction with the bonfire was quickly abandoned and there were more iterations on the vintage poster idea.

To me it looks like the point of view is getting further and further, reaching the helicopter view for the approved cover. The combination of colours of the final cover is lovely!

the optimistic decate heather abel rejected book covers readers high tea
Cover designs by Philip Pascuzzo. Images from electricliterature.com

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo by Stieg Larsson

For a psychological thriller, I consider the book covers to be quite playful, especially the pink and yellow ones. According to the designer, he came up with “dozens of concepts”, so it’s no wonder they are so different.

Oddly, the final cover design is also the most obvious one – it has a dragon image on the background. One of those moments when the easy way is the best way 🙂

the girl with the dragon tattoo stieg larsson readers high tea
Cover designs by Peter Mendelsund. Images from wired.com

Sea Monsters by Chloe Aridjis

In the case of “Sea Monsters”, I find much more appealing the second design on the left (green-ish watercolour) compared to the final design. The first and the third lack depth and do not reflect the “sea monster-ish” aspect of the title.  From this point of view, the green covers seem more appropriate.

sea monsters chloe aridjis rejected book covers readers high tea
Cover designs by Charlotte Strick and Claire Williams. Images from electricliterature.com

Three Novels (Carrie, Salem’s Lot, The Shining) by Stephen King

Despite his popularity, I managed not to read any book by Stephen King so far. And these book designs only confirm my documented assumption that it might not be my cup of tea 🙂

I find it interesting that the three rejected covers included the names of the three novels, while the approved cover summarizes “Three Novels”. In this context it is more appealing keep it simple and write as little text as possible on the cover. The more visual the cover is, the less effort it takes to process it.

three novels stephen king rejected book covers readers high tea
Cover designs by Jim Tierney. Images from electricliterature.com

Thank you for joining me on another journey in the world of book cover design!

‘Till next time … happy reading!

Georgiana


Sources of the pictures: EyeOnDesign.aiga.orgWired.com | ElectricLiterature.com link 1ElectricLiterature.com link 2. Cover photo by Toa Heftiba on Unsplash.

4 thoughts on “Let’s talk about book covers: how do rejected vs approved versions of book covers look?

  1. I enjoyed your post on book covers and to see the different versions that were considered for some popular books. The book cover is pretty important as it might be the thing that first draws you to the book!

    I really enjoy your blog and I nominated you for a blogging award – the Liebster Award! Here is the link to my post with the nomination (see the bottom for the update) – https://tierneycreates.com/2020/05/07/liebster-award-nomination-part-i/
    If you like you can play along and notify your readers of your nomination, answer the 7 questions I posed to you, share 7 facts about yourself and nominate 7 other bloggers (or do any of these activities that interest you). No obligation!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s